Blog

How to translate performance visibility into improvement

Over the last decade, factories have become increasingly data rich, and data collection and visualisation of production line performance is now commonplace. From purpose built systems deploying dedicated sensors, to bolt on OEE modules utilising existing data (e.g. from label verification systems), most report line efficiency, throughput and downtime in digestible formats with trends.

However, we often observe a common theme in factories with such systems rolled out. Data and visualisations alone don’t translate to improvement in line performance – and in some cases, better data actually erodes the discipline that drives performance. To be valuable, data has to be digested and discussed in such a way that it leads a human to behave differently, or to make a different decision.

So why isn’t improved visibility of performance and losses leading to actual performance improvement?

In our experience, it’s because one or more of three critical success factors for driving performance improvement on production lines is missing:

  • People who own the result, not the dashboard
  • Data that distils focus to a small number of valuable outcomes
  • Performance made visible to the factory floor, not just management

People who own the result, not the dashboard

Regardless of data availability, management of performance has always relied on disciplined review of how we did vs a target. For example, when reviewing the last hour’s performance in a line-side Short Interval Control (SIC) meeting on a whiteboard, the conversation was typically: what was throughput vs the plan? What was yield vs the standard?

What better data availability can do is enrich these conversations with better and more accurate information, and reduce the manual burden of collecting and writing down the numbers.

What data availability cannot do is make sure the people that can make a difference (often operators and supervisors) know and understand the numbers, and do something differently as a result.

Therefore the success factor that hasn’t changed is that the people who can make an impact feel ownership of achieving the target, have the capability to achieve it, and are held to account against it.

Unfortunately, what we often see is that better data availability erodes this discipline. Dashboards make people feel closer to the factory floor, when in reality they spend less time on it – time on the line is replaced with time looking at a screen. And if you can see what’s causing downtime without physically watching the line, your understanding of the process, and of what’s actually going wrong, starts to slip.

We often help our clients in this space with:

  • Maintaining discipline of talking about performance at the required frequency (through SIC, daily performance reviews, weekly CI forums and monthly management reviews)
  • Ensuring targets are stretching but achievable (in our last article, we talked about OEE systems leaving money on the table by not balancing visibility of performance vs perfect, with engaging targets for the workforce. Targets need to be achievable to engage their owners)
  • Challenging, not accepting, performance excuses
  • Empowering effective escalation to ensure blockers on the factory floor reach the level that can resolve them
  • Keeping supervisors on the factory floor, as accountability and engagement are driven when they are visible and present

Data that distils focus to a small number of valuable outcomes

Modern systems can capture huge amounts of data, and the temptation is to make it all visible in case it’s required. Whilst the detailed data is great for deep analysis, showing too much information without a clear focus on what results we’re actually trying to drive causes noise and confusion. Reducing focus on the valuable outcomes can actually reduce performance, despite having more data available.

There is also another common pitfall, which is that the more data is available, the more potential there is for it to be wrong. This is particularly true if there is human input involved – for example manually selecting downtime reasons. When there is incorrect data displayed, trust in the overall picture quickly falls.

Different factories also have different measures which drive financial value. For example, depending on the raw material cost, yield may or may not be important. There may be secondary by-products whose yield makes or breaks performance. And different products might require different focusses on quality vs throughput to achieve an efficient run.

Therefore making bespoke visualisations to simply show the few measures that matter, in a way everyone understands, with the detail available separately or behind a click to expand the detail, is very important and often surprisingly difficult. I have seen several factory rollouts of OEE systems in the last 2 years which have simple visualisations, but which are too generic to manage the specific value drivers for that site or process.

In the age of AI, we are increasingly finding that bespoke visuals are faster and cheaper to build and iterate, but also easier and easier to make too complex.

We often help our clients in this space with:

  • Designing simple but powerful performance visuals, tailored to the audience
  • Aligning the time horizon of information shown to the person using it, for example operators hourly, supervisors daily, managers monthly
  • Building trust in the data and coaching people’s understanding of key metrics
  • Reducing manual input, and coaching people where it can’t be avoided
  • Validating data with reality
  • Presenting the detailed data on an as-required basis, in an easy to digest way

Performance made visible to the factory floor, not just management

Detailed analytics and long term trends can be very valuable to managers and CI professionals, helping to guide focus on where to get the best bang for buck on improvement initiatives. However not enough focus is often given to the people that can make the biggest difference to performance – the operators on the line, and the first line engineering support.

This closely links in with culture, where it pays to build an environment where people know what a good day looks like when they come to work, and can clearly see how they and their peers are performing vs that standard. Healthy competition and feeling supported and recognised by supervisors and managers can drive a lot of engagement with line operators.

Once accurate and ideally automated recording of the few measures that matter has been established, it’s important to decide how to make it visible to the factory floor. Too often operators don’t know how well their day has gone until the end of a batch – or worse, shift – and in some cases if a measure is particularly hard to capture or visualise live, such as yield of by-products, they may very rarely see how well they are performing. Performance visibility may also be limited to a line leader at an SIC meeting, but never communicated back to machine operators who can have a significant impact on the line performance.

Technology is often a good enabler, where tablets or similar can be rolled out to individual lines giving operators quick, visual feedback on live performance. Integrating a single view of, for example, giveaway, throughput, and upcoming changeovers, reduces the mental burden and time required for a line leader to check a plan, checkweigher, and machine settings.

Tactically placed screens showing high level live performance by line across a public space can also be a big motivator, encouraging lines to go “green” on the screen and driving healthy competition. Everyone on a line can then see their collective performance rather than it being limited to a line leader. We recently rolled out a screen in a production hall where lines could earn gold stars each shift by hitting key targets. The behaviour of several of the line leaders changed overnight once they could see and be recognised for their hard work.

We often help our clients in this space with:

  • Streamlining data collection and visualisation on the line with technology – e.g. sensors and tablets
  • Ensuring simple visualisation of live performance back to the line
  • Creating more public visibility of live performance across a number of lines
  • Coaching line leaders and operators to understand what they can do to influence the performance of their line

Conclusion

None of these three factors is new, and none of them is solved by technology alone. Better data gives us the opportunity to have better conversations about performance, but only if the right people own the result, focus on the few measures that matter, and can see how they’re doing while there’s still time to act.

Getting all of this right typically takes significantly more up-front effort than simply rolling out a system:

  • Thoughtful data capture
  • Time spent carefully developing and iterating visualisation with key users
  • Coaching of people at all levels during the rollout, both to understand the information, and for managers and leaders, to hold others to account

However, the benefits of getting it right far outweigh the effort, and often play a significant part in the realisation and sustainability of the results we deliver for our clients. Once the system and behaviours are embedded, it is relatively easy to sustain it with the right management direction.

Do any of the points above resonate with you? Let us know what you think, and if you would like to discuss in more detail please get in touch – makeitpossible@majaco.co

Get in touch

Is this happening on your lines?

Tell us what you are seeing. We will be in touch soon.